Skip to content
Free US shipping on orders of $60+
Search
Account
Open cart
Cart
0
$0.00
(
0
)
Open menu
Menu
Explore
Spring Sale!
New
Trending
Bundles
Free Shipping
Scratch & Dent
TTRPGs & Solo Games
Solo Games
Two-Player Games
Fantasy
Horror
Sci-Fi
Mystery
Cozy
Family
Inspiration
Old School
RPG Cards
Show me everything
More Games & Accessories
Dice
Board Games
Card Games
Tarot & Oracle Cards
Playing Cards
Accessories
Journals
Puzzles
Fiction & Non-Fiction
Featured Fiction
Featured Non-Fiction
Last Call Books
Reviews
Read & Reviewed
Community Reviews
Tabletop Bookshelf News
Visit Us
Directions & Parking
A Gaming Destination
Reserve A Table
Milwaukee Events
About
Who We Are
Featured Publishers
Get 10% Off
FAQ
Contact
Menu
Close sidebar
Explore
Back
Spring Sale!
New
Trending
Bundles
Free Shipping
Scratch & Dent
TTRPGs & Solo Games
Back
Solo Games
Two-Player Games
Fantasy
Horror
Sci-Fi
Mystery
Cozy
Family
Inspiration
Old School
RPG Cards
Show me everything
More Games & Accessories
Back
Dice
Board Games
Card Games
Tarot & Oracle Cards
Playing Cards
Accessories
Journals
Puzzles
Fiction & Non-Fiction
Back
Featured Fiction
Featured Non-Fiction
Last Call Books
Reviews
Back
Read & Reviewed
Community Reviews
Tabletop Bookshelf News
Visit Us
Back
Directions & Parking
A Gaming Destination
Reserve A Table
Milwaukee Events
About
Back
Who We Are
Featured Publishers
Get 10% Off
FAQ
Contact
Account
Home
/
Collections
/
Mystery
Mystery
who, what, when, where, why, and how
Filter:
Genre
0 selected
Reset
Fantasy (7)
Sci-Fi (9)
Cyberpunk (1)
Dystopian (1)
Horror (11)
Folk Horror (1)
Historical (1)
Romance (2)
Modern Day (4)
Mystery (39)
Crime (8)
Cozy (7)
Survival (3)
Weird (3)
Drama (3)
Music (1)
Action (1)
Apocalyptic (1)
Supernatural (5)
Comedy (1)
Inspiration (4)
Victorian (1)
Thriller (1)
Player Count
0 selected
Reset
Solo (1 player) (24)
Duet (2 players) (12)
Small Group (3-5) (19)
Play Time
0 selected
Reset
Quick (Under 30 minutes) (1)
Short (30-60 minutes) (9)
Medium (1-2 hours) (19)
Long (2-4 hours) (12)
Campaign (Multiple sessions) (15)
Game System
0 selected
Reset
Old School (3)
Forged in the Dark (1)
Custom (24)
Paragon (1)
Breathless (4)
Savage Worlds (1)
Other (4)
Game Mechanics
0 selected
Reset
Poly dice (12)
Six-sided dice (14)
Tarot cards (4)
Playing cards (18)
Journaling (16)
Letter-writing (2)
Map-making (4)
GM-less (1)
Collaborative (3)
Recommended Ages
0 selected
Reset
Ages 13-17 (Teen) (13)
Ages 18+ (Mature/Adult) (25)
All Ages (Family Friendly) (8)
8+ (1)
13+ (2)
18+ (3)
Complexity
0 selected
Reset
Beginner (26)
Intermediate (11)
Advanced (1)
Type
0 selected
Reset
Board Game (1)
Oracle Cards (1)
RPG Book (10)
RPG Boxed Set (2)
RPG Card Game (1)
RPG Supplement (8)
RPG Zine (16)
Publisher / Creator
0 selected
Reset
Adept Icarus (1)
Almost Bedtime Theater (2)
Arc Dream Publishing (1)
Bannerless Games (4)
Blinking Birch Games (2)
Elliot Davis (2)
Evil Hat Productions (2)
Glyphtide Games (1)
Hatchlings Games (1)
Heltung Storytelling (1)
M. Allen Hall (2)
Outrider Creative (1)
Pandion Games (9)
Possible Worlds Games (1)
Scryptid Games (1)
Snowbright Studio (1)
Soul Muppet Publishing (1)
Table Cat Games (1)
The Gauntlet (1)
The Ravensridge Press (2)
Three Sails Studios (1)
U.S. Games Systems (1)
Price
The highest price is $74.95
Reset
From
$
To
$
Filter
Sort by:
Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort
Filter and sort
Showing 39 products
VOID 1680 AM
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(26)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Hot
Whispers in the Walls
Rating: 4.79 out of 5
(29)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Hot
Lighthouse at the End of the World
Rating: 4.55 out of 5
(11)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Hot
No-Tell Motel
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(5)
$20.95
$20.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $20.95
Add to cart
Hot
The World We Left Behind
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$16.45
$16.45
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $16.45
Add to cart
Anamnesis
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(3)
$14.45
$14.45
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $14.45
Add to cart
Better Strangers
No reviews
No reviews
$19.95
$19.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $19.95
Add to cart
Hot
Substratum Protocol
No reviews
No reviews
$24.95
$24.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $24.95
Add to cart
Hot
The Secret of the Night Market
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(6)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Endling
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$23.95
$23.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $23.95
Add to cart
Project ECCO
No reviews
No reviews
$29.95
$29.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $29.95
Add to cart
Teatime Adventures Core Rulebook
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$24.95
$24.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $24.95
Add to cart
Hot
Waffles for Esther 2e
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(2)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
cyan starlight
Rating: 4.4 out of 5
(5)
$39.95
$39.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $39.95
Add to cart
Camp Snallygaster
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(2)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Psychic Trash Detectives
No reviews
No reviews
$19.95
$19.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $19.95
Add to cart
The Stygian Library - 2025 Reprint
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(4)
$39.95
$39.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $39.95
Add to cart
Hot
Deathmatch Island
No reviews
No reviews
$29.95
$29.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $29.95
Add to cart
Project ECCO Bundle
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$47.49
$50.00
$47.49
$50.00
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $47.49
Add to cart
-5%
Substratum Protocol Solo Journal Pack
No reviews
No reviews
$14.95
$14.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $14.95
Add to cart
Tether
No reviews
No reviews
$10.95
$10.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $10.95
Add to cart
New
Cryptid Creeks
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$44.95
$44.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $44.95
Add to cart
Estate of Play
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$15.95
$15.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $15.95
Add to cart
Mother Mort's Carnival 1897
Rating: 5.0 out of 5
(1)
$36.95
$36.95
Select Title
Default Title
Variants
Default Title - $36.95
Add to cart
Previous
page
1
page
2
1 / 2
Next
Filter and sort
Close sidebar
Sort by:
Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort
Genre
Show more
Fantasy (7)
Sci-Fi (9)
Cyberpunk (1)
Dystopian (1)
Horror (11)
Folk Horror (1)
Historical (1)
Romance (2)
Modern Day (4)
Mystery (39)
Crime (8)
Cozy (7)
Survival (3)
Weird (3)
Drama (3)
Music (1)
Action (1)
Apocalyptic (1)
Supernatural (5)
Comedy (1)
Inspiration (4)
Victorian (1)
Thriller (1)
Player Count
Show more
Solo (1 player) (24)
Duet (2 players) (12)
Small Group (3-5) (19)
Play Time
Show more
Quick (Under 30 minutes) (1)
Short (30-60 minutes) (9)
Medium (1-2 hours) (19)
Long (2-4 hours) (12)
Campaign (Multiple sessions) (15)
Game System
Show more
Old School (3)
Forged in the Dark (1)
Custom (24)
Paragon (1)
Breathless (4)
Savage Worlds (1)
Other (4)
Game Mechanics
Show more
Poly dice (12)
Six-sided dice (14)
Tarot cards (4)
Playing cards (18)
Journaling (16)
Letter-writing (2)
Map-making (4)
GM-less (1)
Collaborative (3)
Recommended Ages
Show more
Ages 13-17 (Teen) (13)
Ages 18+ (Mature/Adult) (25)
All Ages (Family Friendly) (8)
8+ (1)
13+ (2)
18+ (3)
Complexity
Show more
Beginner (26)
Intermediate (11)
Advanced (1)
Type
Show more
Board Game (1)
Oracle Cards (1)
RPG Book (10)
RPG Boxed Set (2)
RPG Card Game (1)
RPG Supplement (8)
RPG Zine (16)
Publisher / Creator
Show more
Adept Icarus (1)
Almost Bedtime Theater (2)
Arc Dream Publishing (1)
Bannerless Games (4)
Blinking Birch Games (2)
Elliot Davis (2)
Evil Hat Productions (2)
Glyphtide Games (1)
Hatchlings Games (1)
Heltung Storytelling (1)
M. Allen Hall (2)
Outrider Creative (1)
Pandion Games (9)
Possible Worlds Games (1)
Scryptid Games (1)
Snowbright Studio (1)
Soul Muppet Publishing (1)
Table Cat Games (1)
The Gauntlet (1)
The Ravensridge Press (2)
Three Sails Studios (1)
U.S. Games Systems (1)
Price
From
$
To
$
Filter
Featured collections
explore the store
Duet Games
Fantasy
Horror
Sci-Fi
Mystery
Romance
Action
Cozy
Inspiration
Customers rate us 4.9/5 based on 540 reviews.
1 product
was added to your cart
View Cart
Close
Shopping Cart (
0
)
Close sidebar
Your cart is currently empty.
0
$0.00
Continue browsing
Search
Close sidebar
Search
